Hold On!

Hold Up

Please select a minimum of three sectors in the menu above.

Got It
  • Have professional reviewers been given two thumbs down?
  • Have professional reviewers been given two thumbs down?
    Newthinking Communications, Creative Commons (2016) ©

Who cares what critics think?

As professional critics lament their ebbing influence on consumers who increasingly rely on the opinions of online peers, the question is being raised of whether top-down reviewers matter anymore. Are crowdsourced reviews – a sort of ‘online word of mouth’ – the only currency that counts?

Location Global

‘Do critics matter?’ The question has been around for years, and has only grown more relevant as consumers increasingly rely on online peer reviews when deciding what music to listen to or film to see, leaving professional critics across media lamenting their ebbing influence.

The guerrilla release of Radiohead’s 2007 album In Rainbows (initially online-only and on a pay-what-you-want model) was heralded as a turning point in the fightback against reviewers – a moment when artists decided critics were expendable and when word of mouth, not professional reviews, came to the fore. [1] Now, albums are released ...



  • Article image Yelp Elite: breaking bread with the everyday expert

    Launched in 2004, Yelp has grown to include more than 50 million businesses worldwide. And it’s transformed how people find a place to eat; we now rely on tips from internet strangers. But thanks to Yelp Elite, some of these strangers are more powerful than others. So who are these influencers?

  • Article image Who really trusts an online review?

    With over 61% of people reading online reviews before making a purchase decision, it’s even more important than ever to separate the good ones from the bad. But with peer reviews and professional write-ups often having contrasting opinions, who should we trust – and why?

  • Article image The rise of the celebrity 'expert'

    Authority is slipping away from 'traditional' experts – and into the hands of celebrities. But is 'standing out' from a sea of products as simple as putting a famous face on a brand?

  • Article image Search for an Expert

    The authority figure has returned to a position of influence as a reaction to widespread consumer distrust.